Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead

Verdict: ⭐️⭐️ (reviewed Sunday 24 August 2025).

Tom Stoppard’s Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead is an absurdist, existential comic-tragedy based on Shakespeare’s Hamlet. The titular characters who appear as offsiders in Shakespeare’s play are thrown onto centre stage to witness the Hamlet plotline from their own perspective, compelling them to question their own identity and agency in the narrative. Were they sent for? Can they say no?

Over the years the play has been hailed as an iconic, brilliant piece of theatre that innovatively uses all the theatrical devices available; a play within a play; witty word games, philosophical discourse and much, much more. Although it’s almost impossible not to compare any stage production to the film version directed by Stoppard himself, the play’s novelty and charm continues to surprise and delight audiences thanks to its intellectually stimulating themes, sharp writing, biting sarcasm and offbeat comedic timing.

So, what went wrong here?

Not only was the theatre house pitifully empty on a Sunday matinee show, but audience members – long term supporters of Hunter’s Hill Theatre – walked out at interval and did not return, complaining to box office that the play was the ‘most dreadful one they had seen in 20 years’.

The run time is taxing – 2 hours and 45 minutes with two intervals, with Act 1 running for just over an hour.

The wordy script is not the issue – Stoppard’s play has a particular cadence and rhythm that commands a savvy director at the helm to find its comedic timing.

The committed cast are not the issue, evidently trying their best to wade through the challenging script, though key lines for inexplicable reasons were fluffed, dropped or mangled altogether, losing the momentum to land the punchlines. The cast seemed to carry a shadow of tension between them, creating a very awkward and disjointed performance.

The beginning of Act 2 is much more promising than Act 1, in which the character of the Player laments (without irony) that the ‘audience has left us’. Rosencrantz finds a sense of urgency and motivation in wanting to know how and why they got there. There is kindling interest in the stakes.

Act 3 gives us the finale of their doomed ending at Elsinore, after much skirmish shenanigans aboard a ship.

The setting is a grotesque vomit-pink flooding the stage as if to create an anti-establishment atmosphere. The characters in Hamlet including Hamlet, Claudius, Polonious and Gertrude are conveyed only through shadow puppetry, which is both intriguing and amateurish.

Director Tui Clark at interval explained her intention was to ‘strip away’ any reference to the Elizabethan-era from which Hamlet originates, and create a fresh, modern approach of ‘these two long time companions going on a wild journey’. Clark quoted an interview from Stoppard in which he said ‘the play has not been disrespected enough.’

As much as that quote can be open to interpretation, it’s doubtful that Stoppard meant ‘lazy’. If it was meant to be lazy, he wouldn’t have crafted such an intricate, thought-provoking script.

Despite poor ticket sales and audience reception, the show must go on. Hunter’s Hill Theatre are to be commended for standing by the director’s artistic vision, and at the very least, allowing us to exercise our our own agency in this existential mess.

Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead is playing at Hunter’s Hill Theatre til 14 September. For tickets and showtimes, go to https://www.huntershilltheatre.com.au/


CREDITS

CAST

KAREN PATTINSON  Rosencrantz 
JIVAN DRUNGILAS  Guildenstern 
PAULINE GARDNER  
The Player 
NATHAN HEINRICH  
Musician–Tragedian / Claudius 
NASH WILLIAMS  Hamlet / Tragedian
MURPHY SCOTT  Alfred / Polonius / Soldier 
ANDREA PINNOCK  Ophelia/ Gertrude

PRODUCTION TEAM

TUI CLARK  Director/Set Designer 
THEO HATZISTERGOS  Assistant Director
WAYNE CHEE  Lighting Design
PETER TUCKER Sound Design
HELEN KOLHAGEN   Costumes 
PAMELA PRICE  Set Painting & Building
MAGGIE SCOTT  Production Manager 
MEG JOHNSON  Stage Manager 

Related Posts