Verdict: ⭐️⭐️⭐️.5 (reviewed Friday 7 April)
The Crucible by Arthur Miller has appeared on the English HSC syllabus for quite some time, so it is a real gift for current students to see a live production at Start of the Sea Theatre in Manly. This play is a fictionalised reenactment of the Salem witch trials in 1692-93, where several men and women were trialled and hung for witchcraft. Miller wrote his play in response to the ‘witch hunting’ of communists during the McCarthy administration. No one with even a hint of liberal thinking was safe; personalities like Lucille Ball and Charlie Chaplin came under fire, as did Miller himself for refusing to share names of any potential suspects. This play examines this repugnant side of human nature, the ease at which people can be falsely accused and victimised, and the demonising of women as witches. For many centuries witch hunting has been the norm for puritanical communities gripped by paranoia and fear, and while we don’t burn victims at the stake anymore, we still use use the label of ‘witch’ as a derogatory term and call for blood if the celebrity we once idolised no longer measures up. Our predatory instincts from prehistoric times may have been tamed, made more civilised, but we have never fully evolved from it.
With a sparse setting, minimalist props and muted costuming against a black background, the focus and weight to create a riveting atmosphere very much falls to the actors. Thankfully, this production has the gravitas to keep a restive teenage audience engaged, from seasoned thespians to relative newcomers. The best scenes are the ones of heightened dramatic conflict, such as when the men in the courtroom become as emotional and hysterical as the women that are being accused. There is passion and energy to keep the pace going.
Some earlier scenes, however, have a few lines that are too softly spoken to be audibly heard, even by people sitting in the front row. At other times, the dialogue can be verbose and rushed, giving more urgency that is perhaps required. The accents are also inconsistent across the cast, creating geographical ambiguity of the setting (The Crucible is set in Salem, Massachusetts, to be exact). The voices are rich with sanctimonious zeal, but the accents are a bit too generalised to impart the power of unison and the climate of repression, fear and conformity in a small community, where people talk and gossip.
Notwithstanding this, the audience highly appreciated this esteemed effort by the entire cast and directors Paul Winchester and Blair Cutting (who also appear in the play).
The cast features Paul Winchester, Melissa Jones, Steve Allnutt, Theo Rule, Oliver Harcourt, Amelie Stone, Catherine Gilbert, Penny day, Max Dÿkstra, Branko Dÿkstra, Michael Richmond, Josephine Waller, Aska karem, Isabella Coffey, Katherine Taylor, Thea Ward, Sam Jeffries, Owen Frost, Blair Cutting.
The Crucible presented by Point Break Drama Theatre Company is playing at the Star of Sea Theatre in Manly till 13 April 2024. For tickets and showtimes, go to https://www.trybooking.com/events/landing/1174664