Brontë by Polly Teale has received mixed reviews since its first run in 2005. On the one hand reviews say it is a deeply romantic portrayal of the Brontë siblings and their enduring literary legacy. Others say it is a rather stilted and inert account of their tragically short and troubled lives.

This production at Genesian Theatre falls somewhere in the middle; Brontë fans that I spoke to afterwards told me they enjoyed the biographical and literary references sprinkled throughout the play. Those that weren’t as familiar found it lagging. The choppy, overly crammed script seems to the crux of the problem; without a strong, cohesive narrative it all sounds a bit airy-fairy, forced and bloviated. The cast do their best to show urgency of their deepest passions, but the vocal delivery comes across as generalised, contrived and over-rehearsed. Even so, there are some obvious slip-ups, drying and lighting issues which are all handled with bravado. Anneka Brownsberger makes Charlotte Brontë by far the most interesting character, with strong stage presence and a well modulated voice, expressing passion and disdain with convincing austerity.

The exquisite, spine-tingling score by Michael Schell is criminally underused, played only as bookended / intermission music; without it, the sound of static leaves the production feeling a bit clinical and cold.

The set design by Tom Fahy is beautifully done, with an enchanting starry night exterior seen behind a window pane and translucent curtains around a bed to convey the tragedy of sudden illness and death. Crowded bookshelves painted onto wooden panels, which are mounted in full visibility of the audience is a nice touch; the script calls for actors to briefly discuss auditioning for the play before changing into period costume, with stage crew around them getting the scene ready for action.

Overall, this production has some wonderful theatrical elements behind it, making it appealing to fans of Brontë and period drama, but for the plus one attendees, the overall result may seem a bit protracted and underwhelming.

Brontë is playing at Genesian Theatre until 22 July 2023. For tickets and showtimes, go to https://www.genesiantheatre.com.au/

_____________________
Images: Craig O’Regan

Related Posts